Most electrical contractors get workers’ comp through an agency that places electrical accounts with insurers in the voluntary market. If those insurers decline, every state has a residual market for employers that cannot find coverage, and in North Dakota, Ohio, Washington and Wyoming the state fund covers every employer. Start with a specialist agency and a complete submission.
Where does workers’ comp for electrical employees come from?
From one of three places, depending on the state and the account. In most states, private insurers write workers’ compensation in what is called the voluntary market, and an agency presents your account to the insurers that want electrical work. When no insurer in the voluntary market will write an account, the state’s residual market provides coverage as a last resort. And in a small group of states, a state fund is the only source of coverage. The workers’ compensation page explains how each of these works for electrical crews.
The order matters. The voluntary market usually offers the best terms, the residual market is a safety net, and the state funds are not a choice where they apply. A contractor that understands the order spends its effort where it pays: presenting the account well enough that voluntary insurers want it.
Why start with an agency that writes electrical contractors?
Because electrical work is a class that some insurers seek out and others avoid. Shock, arc flash and falls make it a high-severity class, and insurers that write it want to see payroll classified correctly, a safety program that addresses energized work and a loss history they can read. An agency that knows which insurers write electrical payroll can take one complete submission to the right ones instead of shopping it everywhere. Our post on which insurance agency specializes in electrical contractors covers how to tell a specialist from a generalist.
The specialist’s value also shows up after the policy is written. Classification, audits and claims are where workers’ compensation goes wrong for electrical contractors, and an agency that understands the class can catch a misclassification before it becomes an audit bill. Our post on workers’ compensation for electricians explains how class codes and experience modifiers work.
What is the residual market, and when do you need it?
It is the coverage of last resort for employers that cannot buy workers’ compensation in the voluntary market, often called the assigned risk plan. A new electrical business with no history, an account with recent serious claims or a business working in a segment insurers are avoiding may end up there. Each state runs its own residual market arrangement, and an agency can apply on your behalf.
Coverage through the residual market is real coverage, and it meets the legal requirement where one applies. The terms and pricing are usually less favorable, though, so most contractors treat it as a bridge. Building a clean loss record, documenting a safety program and keeping payroll classified correctly are what bring an account back to the voluntary market. Our post on workers’ comp cost levers covers the steps that matter most.
What about the monopolistic states?
In North Dakota, Ohio, Washington and Wyoming, workers’ compensation is bought from the state fund rather than from private insurers. An electrical contractor with employees in one of those states gets the statutory benefit there, and an agency cannot place that part with a private insurer. The gap to watch is employers liability, which the state fund may not provide in the same way, so contractors there often need separate coverage for it, sometimes called stop-gap coverage.
If you work in one of these states and others, the program needs both pieces: the state fund for the monopolistic state and a private policy for the rest. Our post on workers’ comp for electrical firms with multiple locations covers how that combination is set up. Each state page on this site notes how workers’ compensation works where we have verified it.
Do you have to carry workers’ comp at all?
In most states, an employer with employees is required to carry it, though the rules vary by state, by how the business is organized and sometimes by the number of employees. Texas is a notable exception, where workers’ compensation is generally elective for most private employers, though general contractors and utilities can require it regardless. Rules about whether owners and officers are covered or can be excluded also differ by state and by entity type. Our post on business structure for an electrical contractor explains how the entity can affect that question.
Even where it is not required, electrical contractors usually carry it, because the work is dangerous and customers commonly ask for proof. Questions about your state’s rules can go to your state insurance department, which you can find through the NAIC directory of state insurance departments, or to the state’s workers’ compensation agency.
What should you have ready before you ask for a quote?
A complete file gets a better answer from more insurers. Prepare:
- Payroll by type of work, split the way the classes are split.
- A description of the work: residential, commercial and industrial, or power-line.
- Loss runs from prior insurers, or a note that the business is new.
- The states where employees work and where they are based.
- Your safety program, including how crews are trained for energized work.
- Whether you use subcontractors, and whether you collect their certificates.
New businesses can still present well. A new electrical contractor without loss history can show the owner’s experience, the training plan for new hires and the safety rules the crew will follow. Our post on arc flash, electrocution and workers’ comp explains why underwriters focus so closely on how energized work is handled.
How do subcontractors and staffing agencies affect where you buy?
They affect what the policy has to account for. Workers’ compensation audits commonly look at payments to subcontractors, and an uninsured subcontractor can be treated as part of your payroll. Before you buy, decide how you will collect and keep current certificates from every subcontractor, and tell the insurer how much of your work is subcontracted. Insurers read a contractor that manages its subcontractors well as a better account.
Staffing agencies work differently, because the agency is usually the employer of record for the electricians it places. Our post on workers’ comp for electrical staffing agencies explains how coverage divides between the agency and the contractor that directs the work. Tell your agent if you use agency labor, so your own policy and audit treat it correctly.
How does pay-as-you-go billing fit in?
It is a way of paying for the policy, not a separate source of coverage. With pay-as-you-go, the premium is calculated from actual payroll as each payroll is run, rather than from an estimate paid up front and corrected at the audit. For an electrical contractor whose payroll swings with the season or a large project, it can smooth cash flow and reduce surprises at audit. Whether it is available depends on the insurer and the payroll service, so ask your agent. It does not change where the coverage comes from or what the policy covers, and the audit still happens; it simply moves the reconciliation closer to the payroll itself.
Real-World Scenario: A new electrical contractor hires its first two electricians and applies for workers’ comp through a general agency that sends a thin application to a few insurers. Each one declines, and the business is placed in the state’s residual market. A year later, with a clean record and a written safety program, the owner moves to a specialist agency. It sends a complete submission to insurers that write electrical payroll, and the account returns to the voluntary market at renewal.
What if the current insurer non-renews your comp?
Move straight to a complete submission rather than waiting. A non-renewal sets a date, and a lapse in workers’ compensation can expose the business to penalties where coverage is required and stop work on contracts that require proof. Our post on what to do after an electrical contractor insurance non-renewal walks through that process, and the residual market is there if the voluntary market does not respond in time.
What is the next step?
Send your payroll by type of work, the states where your crews work and your loss runs with a quote request. We present the account to insurers that write electrical payroll, and we tell you plainly if the residual market or a state fund is part of the answer.